vSphere Express vs HPE VM Essentials vs Proxmox for SMB Customers

vSphere express is an entry level fixed 128 core one year subscription for small customers without paying the full fee for the VCF/VVF private cloud stack.

This is the vSphere Essentials Plus and its back with the distributed switch which was missing in Essentials Plus earlier. This is meant as a retention play to keep the small VMware customers leaving for Proxmox or Hpe VM Essentials.

Who is it for

vSphere Standard customers at renewal who do not want VVF or VCF and customers with just 3-4 hosts on a existing NAS/SAN.

This is a poor fit for estates over 128 core or who is looking to grow past this limit.

What 128 cores means in servers

128 cores is two to eight typical hosts in total, across your whole estate so it somewhat looks like this.

Host configCounted cores per hostMax hosts in 128
1 x 16-core168
2 x 8-core32 (16-core floor)4
2 x 16-core324
2 x 24-core482
2 x 32-core642

Comparison Between Hpe VM Essentials vs Proxmox vs vSphere Express

This is an approx. pricing from other websites just to give you an idea but check with resellers.

It is cheap next to VVF and VCF. It is not cheap next to the old vSphere Standard, Proxmox or HPE VM Essentials, and small estates overpay.

Express works out to $75 per core i think, so On the 32-core estate it is effectively $300 per physical core, more than VVF.

Platform4 hosts, 2 x 16-core
(128 cores, 8 sockets)
2 hosts, 1 x 16-core
(32 cores, 2 sockets)
VMware VCF ($350/core)$44,800$11,200
VMware VVF ($135/core)$17,280$4,320
vSphere Express (fixed pack)$9,600$9,600
Old vSphere Standard ($50/core, vSphere 8 only)$6,400$1,600
Proxmox VE Standard (EUR 550/socket)~$5,000~$1,260
HPE VM Essentials ($600/socket)$4,800$1,200

What’s in the box

IncludedNot included
ESX and vCenter StandardDRS
vMotion (faster in vSphere 9)vSAN
High AvailabilityMemory tiering
vSphere Distributed SwitchGPU support
vCenter Quick PatchAdvanced Services add-ons
TPM 2.0 and vTPM 2.0

The only major loss in here is DRS and vSAN. DRS allows sorf of even VM placement orload balancing and this goes back to being manual. If you are coming from Kubernetes world you will understand DRS doesn’t apply there too. Any new workloads will move into hosts which are less utilized and the current workload stays there. A concept of scheduler pod in Kubernetes does the job of drifting workloads to ease compute pressure on a node so a similar thing can be done as well via scripts etc to improve load balancing so nothing major is really lost.

No vSAN is included in Express which means no HCI and yo will need to rely on native san protocols like FC, SAN or ISCSI for storage.

Licensing and price

Express is a single fixed pack: 128 cores, one year, about $9,600.

The rules, as resellers describe them:

  • Fixed size. You always pay for 128 cores, even if you run 32.
  • One pack per customer. The 128-core cap applies across all your environments, not per cluster or site. No expansion beyond it.
  • Subscription only. Nothing perpetual.
  • Sold through distributors. It comes via two-tier distribution marketplaces, not Broadcom’s partner list.

The HPE VM Essentials alternative

HPE VM Essentials is the closest like-for-like rival: about half the price of Express at 128 cores, with DRS-style placement included. The trade-off is a new hypervisor.

It runs a KVM-based hypervisor (HVM) and can also manage existing VMware VMs from the same console, which helps with phased migrations. Pricing is $600 per CPU socket per year at suggested list, support included, on 1-, 3- or 5-year terms. There is no core minimum, so dense CPUs cost nothing extra.

vSphere ExpressHPE VM Essentials
HypervisorESX (vSphere 9)KVM-based HVM
LicenceFixed 128-core pack, 1 yearPer socket, 1, 3 or 5 years
Size limit128 cores, all environmentsNone
Live migration and HAYesYes
Automatic workload placementNo (no DRS)Yes
Storage live migrationNot listedYes
Built-in backupNoYes
Shared storageFC, iSCSI, NFSFC, iSCSI (GFS2), NFS
Upgrade pathVVF, VCFMorpheus Enterprise

Express is a useful bridge for small, stable vSphere estates on shared storage, at roughly $9,600 a year. It is not a return to the old, cheap, perpetual VMware. Also, the hard 128-core ceiling makes it a poor home for anything that grows.

If staying on vSphere is the priority, Express is the cheapest way onto vSphere 9. If cost is the priority and a migration is acceptable, HPE VM Essentials or Proxmox will cost less and do not cap your growth.

(Visited 4 times, 8 visits today)

By Ash Thomas

Ash Thomas is a seasoned IT professional with extensive experience as a technical expert, complemented by a keen interest in blockchain technology.